Skip to main content
Arborist Group

Blog

Ontario Butternut Rules in 2026: New Assessments Use the SCA

Published November 5, 2026

By The Arborist Group

Ontario changed the legal framework for Butternut on March 30, 2026. The Species Conservation Act, 2025 replaced the Endangered Species Act process, but Butternut remains listed as endangered. If an old report or web page tells you to sort a new assessment into Category 1, 2 or 3, stop there. Those categories are not part of a new assessment under the current rules.

The advanced-canker exception now depends on a Schedule 3 report and notice through the Species Conservation Registry before the day anyone first engages in the activity. Other activities, such as removing a healthy Butternut, must be registered instead. An old file can also carry transition conditions that do not apply to a new one.

The Species Conservation Act and its current regulations took effect on March 30, 2026. That is the legal change date. Ontario’s plain-language Butternut guidance, published September 23, 2026, came later and did not change that date.

Butternut, Juglans cinerea, remains an endangered vascular plant under O. Reg. 60/26. The new statute still controls work that kills or harms a protected species, or damages or destroys its habitat. For a vascular plant, the Act defines habitat as the critical root zone surrounding the plant.

That wording matters if your project notes still use a blanket 25 m circle. The Act does not fix a distance. The assessor measures the critical root zone for each tree. The 25 m figure belonged to the former regulatory framework and should not be copied into a new SCA assessment as though it were still the rule.

New Assessments Do Not Use Categories

Ontario now says this plainly: SCA regulations do not categorize Butternut trees as Category 1, Category 2 or Category 3. Those were ESA categories.

You may still find category language in an old file. O. Reg. 62/26 preserves a narrow exception for work affecting a Butternut identified as Category 1 in the specified former report, provided that report reached the Ministry before March 30, 2026. Other old, ministry-confirmed notice files can fall under separate deemed-registration rules and keep their former conditions alive.

A Category 1 label on a qualifying transition report can still have legal effect. It does not bring Category 1, 2 and 3 back as the system for a new assessment. If your report or Ministry confirmation predates March 30, have that specific file reviewed before you replace it or assume the old conditions disappeared.

Advanced Canker Has a Specific Exception

A qualified Butternut professional must identify canker that is advanced enough that retaining the tree would not support local protection or recovery, then document that finding in a Schedule 3 report.

The next step is notice, not a permit application or an activity registration. The Exception Information Form and Schedule 3 report go through the Species Conservation Registry before the day anyone first engages in the activity. The current rule does not carry forward the former mandatory 30-day wait.

The professional needs the expertise, education, training and experience to assess Butternut health. The regulation says the professional may be an arborist, a registered professional forester, a forest technician, a dendrologist, a horticultural technician, a botanist or a mycologist. The occupation alone is not the test, and the former Butternut Health Expert designation is not the current statutory gate for this exception.

Schedule 3 Sets the Current Report Content

Schedule 3 breaks the report into five information groups. It calls for:

  • the professional’s name and contact information, plus the report completion date
  • a description of the professional’s qualifications and supporting documents
  • a description of the planned activity and its anticipated start and end dates
  • identification of each affected Butternut that meets the advanced-canker test
  • for each identified tree, its location and coordinates, assessment date, whether the stem reaches at least 1.37 metres and its diameter at that height if it does, the reasons for the determination, and at least one photograph.

Ontario is still developing guidance and reporting templates for the SCA framework. The Ministry says the old assessment guidelines can still inform a health determination, but they do not reflect current law. For the interim reporting template, Ontario directs people to SAROntario@ontario.ca.

The old May 15 to August 31 assessment window came from ESA guidance. Schedule 3 does not print that fixed seasonal window as a current legal requirement. No fixed legal window applies. Crown condition can only be assessed in leaf, so we schedule assessments in the growing season.

Other Activities Follow a Different Lane

An advanced-canker finding does not open the same route for every Butternut project. If the exception does not apply, removing or harming a healthy Butternut, or damaging its habitat, is a registrable activity. It must be registered under O. Reg. 75/26 before work starts. A permit applies only to the activities listed in the Permit Activities Regulation, O. Reg. 74/26.

A new registration under O. Reg. 75/26 requires a conservation plan prepared by one or more qualified professionals whose collective competence covers the species and habitat in the plan. They must use the best available information. A project already confirmed under the old regime may instead fall under O. Reg. 62/26 and continue under its former conditions.

Work affecting Butternut at the nut stage sits outside this approval path, as do the listed possession, transport, collection and trade activities involving Butternut or its parts. That does not authorize harming or removing the tree that produced the nuts.

Four Old Rules That No Longer Apply

Four pieces of old advice should not drive a new file:

  • assigning Category 1, 2 or 3 to a newly assessed tree;
  • drawing a universal 25 m habitat circle around every Butternut;
  • treating May 15 to August 31 as the current statutory assessment window;
  • waiting 30 days after an advanced-canker exception submission because the former regulation required it.

Getting the Current Assessment Filed

If the assessment supports the advanced-canker exception, The Arborist Group offers the full Butternut assessment and Species Conservation Registry submission. We prepare the assessment and submit the Exception Information Form with the Schedule 3 report. The assessment report arrives within 2 business days of the site visit.

If the exception does not apply, the project must be registered under O. Reg. 75/26, and the registration needs a conservation plan prepared by qualified professionals. Confirm the documentation requirements before work starts.

Contact us with the property location, the planned work and any old Butternut report or Ministry confirmation already on file.

24-Hour Response GuaranteedSubmit below or call (647) 479-8778

Get a quote

Tell us about your property. An ISA Certified Arborist will reply with a firm quote.

  • Free consultation, response within 24 hours.
  • Assessment report within 2 business days of the site visit.
  • We do not sell tree removal.

Serving Toronto, the GTA and Southern Ontario.

ISA Certified Arborist  ·  ISA Member  ·  ISA Ontario Member

Get Your Free Consultation

Service Needed